Butter Maid Bakery Reviews
Butter Maid Bakery has an overall rating of 4.5 based on 22 reviews. Customer feedback on Butter Maid Bakery is mixed: Butter Maid Bakery reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious baked goods, excellent customer service, fast shipping and fresh ingredients, which strongly appeal to baking enthusiasts and gift shoppers. However, Butter Maid Bakery is often criticized for its higher price point, limited product variety, occasional shipping delays.
22 reviews
5 Stars
11
4 Stars
10
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate Butter Maid Bakery?
All Butter Maid Bakery Reviews (22)
carl1987
May 24, 2026
"This was really tasty stuff. You…"
This was really tasty stuff. You can tell they actually care about what they’re making, which feels like the right way to do it. No cutting corners, just good food that deserves the praise.
0
Reply
huey_Hansen88
May 19, 2026
"The site looks nice overall..."
The site looks nice overall. The photos are clean and browsing has been easy so far, though I’m still a little confused about where a few things are supposed to be.
0
Reply
Michael_brandes01
April 28, 2026
"Worth it for a weekend treat"
I ordered from Butter Maid Bakery for a family weekend, it was worth the money. The box have a good amount in it, and everything tasted fresh instead of dry or cheap. The prices feels fair for what you get, especially compared to bakeries around me. I’d definitely order again, probably not every week, but for treats or gifts it makes sense
0
Reply
CharlieLenderman_53
April 23, 2026
"Good selection, but the filters need work"
There are a lot of choices, which is nice, but it took me a while to figure out what I wanted. The filter could definitely be easier to use, whoever runs this really needs to clean that up a bit.
0
Reply
RobinGaters_79
April 18, 2026
"I tried a few of the cookies, the..."
I tried a few of the cookies, the texture was probably my favorite part. They had that soft, kind of chewy middle that I really like, but still had a little crispness around the edges so they didn’t feel too mushy or underbaked. I also had one of the brownies, and while the flavor was still good, it was just a little denser than I personally prefer. Not bad at all, just more on the heavy side. Overall though, I enjoyed everything and would definitely order again.
0
Reply
chrystalharrold3017
April 17, 2026
"Nice little gift that went over well"
I sent a cookie tray to my aunt and she was really happy with it. She mentioned the packaging looked pretty, so it definitely felt gift-worthy when it arrived. It did show up a day later than expected, but that didn’t seem to take away from the surprise.
0
Reply
Richard_coleman82
April 10, 2026
"I ordered from Butter Maid Bakery and..."
I ordered from Butter Maid Bakery and everything tasted really fresh. I liked the pastries overall, I just wish a few of them had a little more filling inside. Still enjoyed them for sure, but that extra bit would make them perfect for me
0
Reply
YOUNG
March 27, 2026
"Ingredient info was helpful, just a little unclear"
I liked that I could actually find the ingredients easy before I ordered. That was helpful. Some of the flavors could maybe have more details tho, cause I wasnt totally sure on a couple, but overall it was good.
0
Reply
Robert_burns85
March 26, 2026
"Bigger portions than I expected"
I ordered from Butter Maid Bakery and, i wasn’t totally sure what to expect. I kind of assumed the box would be smaller or maybe the pieces wouldn’t be that big, but I was wrong. Everything was packed really full and the portions were way more generous than I thought they’d be. I actually felt like I got my money’s worth, which doesn’t always happen. I’d definitely order again.
0
Reply
blake_Gonzalez86
March 12, 2026
"Actually showed up when promised"
The cookies arrived right on time, which feels like something not every company manages to get right. They were fresh, packed well, and tasted perfect
0
Reply
dona-Hang
February 26, 2026
"They usually have it, but it's still frustrating"
They usually have most of what I’m looking for, and yeah, a lot of stuff was in stock. But it’s annoying when the few things I actually need are missing, and it feels like no one there is paying attention to keeping shelves properly stocked.
0
Reply
alishaestey4346
February 14, 2026
"Arrived Quickly and in Great Shape"
I placed an order last minute and was a little nervous it wouldn’t get there in time. But I got the shipping email really quickly, and the box showed up just two days later. Everything was packed nicely too—no broken or smashed cookies. I was genuinely happy with how smooth it all went and would definitely order again when I need to send a gift.
0
Reply
Cheryl-markley
February 05, 2026
"I’ll admit, I wasn’t expecting much, but the..."
I’ll admit, I wasn’t expecting much, but the order was actually really easy to keep tabs on. I got tracking emails along the way, so I knew when it was going to show up. It arrived on time, everything was packed fine, i didn’t have any issues.
0
Reply
David.brooks
January 21, 2026
"Helpful customer service, just a little slow"
I had a question about my order from buttermaidbakery, and customer service did get back to me in a really kind way. They explained the shipping timing and were able to fix my address before the order went out, which was a relief. The only reason I’m giving 4 stars is because the reply took a bit longer than I was hoping... but overall, they were nice and everything got handled just fine.
0
Reply
jeannette_Nichols79
January 08, 2026
"Good packaging"
The packaging was really good, honestly. Everything came safe and looked like it was packed with care, so no complaints from me there.
0
Reply
Jeff-ponds
January 04, 2026
"Finally, an order that was actually right"
Got exactly what I ordered, which shouldn’t feel like a huge win, but here we are. Everything was in the box, nothing missing, nothing weird swapped out, no surprise nonsense. Just the right stuff delivered like it was supposed to be. Kind of refreshing, honestly
0
Reply
AmberGuerra
December 27, 2025
"Worked out better than I expected"
I ordered from Butter Maid Bakery mostly because I wanted to have something on hand for later, and the box came with a note about how to store them. I left a few out to snack on right away and put the rest in the freezer, figuring I’d see how they held up. A couple weeks later I thawed some, and they still tasted fresh. No odd texture or freezer weirdness, which was what I was a little worried about. Simple overall, and I’m happy I tried it.
0
Reply
Judy.bringle
December 23, 2025
"Allergen info was “easy enough” to find"
The allergen notes were clear and easy to spot, which I appreciated. I just wish there was a bit more detail included so I could feel “fully confident” before ordering.
0
Reply
norris-Granda
December 16, 2025
"Fresh cookies that disappeared fast"
These cookies tasted really fresh, they didn’t last long in our house at all. I always feel better buying treats that seem thoughtfully made, like someone actually cared about what they were putting out into the world. Definitely a good choice if you want something sweet that feels worth sharing.
0
Reply
robertdoby1465
December 05, 2025
"Super Easy to Order!!"
Ordering was really easy and straightforward!! I didn’t have to overthink anything, and the whole process went smoothly from start to finish.
0
Reply
Have a question about Butter Maid Bakery?
Log in to ask your Butter Maid Bakery question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
